serverAppConfigs/serverAppConfigs-docs/LLM/LLM Performance Diagnosis.md

---
type: reference
title: LLM Performance Diagnosis
description: Probing why a served LLM is slow — the flat-depth probe, the expert-offload duty-cycle arithmetic, kernel-time attribution via the profiler window, live telemetry without benchmarking, RAM-bandwidth ceilings, IBS tensor attribution and prefix-cache-aware routing.
tags: [performance, profiling, moe, pcie, prefix-cache, routing, telemetry]
timestamp: 2026-10-05T00:00:00-07:00
---

# LLM Performance Diagnosis

When a served endpoint is slower than wanted and someone names a suspect
("PCIe is saturated", "the gather is the bound"), throughput arithmetic cannot
settle it — it is usually circular (it assumes the suspect consumes the step).
Get data in this order; the profiler window alone has retired multi-day
optimization plans.

## 1. Is decode context-bound at all? (the flat-depth probe)

Sweep decode across context depth. **Flat** ⇒ attention over history is not
the cost; the problem is per-token expert movement and KV/attention tuning is
ruled out entirely. A genuinely context-bound server shows a clear downward
slope. Record cold vs warm separately — a small gap means the cache is
working. Measured on the fp8 expert-offload shape: 12.11 tok/s FLAT from 304
to 16,095 tokens.

## 2. Duty-cycle arithmetic (the "GPU not fully utilized" answer)

Symptom: smooth ~25–35 % utilization with 100 % peaks on an expert-offload
MoE. This is the EXPECTED signature, not a fault:

```
per decode step: compute burst ~100 ms (100 %) → expert-gather wait ~400 ms (~0 %)
resident fraction = arena slots / total experts   (e.g. 6574/24576 ≈ 27 %)
PCIe bytes/token  = miss_rate × lookups × slab_bytes  (0.73 × 480 × 2.344 MiB ≈ 0.84 GB)
predicted duty    ≈ compute_ms / (compute_ms + wait_ms)
```

Validate the terms against the deployed engine's boot plan
([[RDNA4 MoE Expert Offload VRAM Budget]]). If predicted ≈ observed, the low
average is structural. Note small-transfer reality: bulk bandwidth (91 % of
ceiling at 1 GiB) overstates what 2–3 MiB slabs get (~72 % plus ~20 %
per-transfer latency). Before blaming the link, measure it
([[PCIe Link and Atomics]]) and compare the engine's effective gather rate to
the measured slab-size bandwidth — a 40–50 % gap is the software read path,
not the wire. `rocm-smi --showuse` reads ~0 % during the whole multi-minute
weight load: show VRAM (`--showmeminfo vram`) as the load-progress signal.

## 3. Kernel-time attribution (the profiler window)

Run BEFORE building any replacement kernel.

1. Stop + mask production; boot the shape under test with ONLY the profiler
   config added. vLLM argv:
   `--profiler-config '{"profiler":"torch","torch_profiler_dir":"/prof","torch_profiler_with_stack":false,"torch_profiler_record_shapes":false,"torch_profiler_with_memory":false,"torch_profiler_dump_cuda_time_total":false}'`
   — `with_stack=false` is load-bearing (with stacks the stop hangs and the
   trace buffer grows ~40 GB → kernel OOM-kill of the engine core, anon-rss
   ~95 GB; the worker-side stop can hang 5 min on ROCm/kineto). Bind-mount
   `/prof`. If a shell substitutes values into that JSON, verify the escapes
   actually landed.
2. Window it: warm request → `POST /start_profile` → N generations of ≥128
   tokens (~15 s of traffic) → `POST /stop_profile` (client may time out at
   60 s; the trace still lands). `telemetry_report` has ONE caller: the
   gpu_worker profiler-stop path. Overhead is small enough to keep decode
   comparable (9.6 vs 9.9–10.0 tok/s measured).
3. **Parse ON THE SERVER** (traces are 100–150 MB gzipped, GB expanded).
   Rank `ph=="X"` events with `cat in {kernel, gpu_memcpy, gpu_memset}` by
   summed `dur` (µs): report % of device time, launch count AND µs/call
   (22 µs × 708k launches is a different problem than 4 ms × 4k), plus the
   first-to-last event span (fraction of wall the device was busy). Aggregate
   by FULL mangled name (template args are the tuning signal) and by stripped
   symbol. **Trap: `gpu_user_annotation` events masquerade as GPU time** (a
   naive sum reported 63 % in one `execute_context_0(...)` entry; spans
   overlap and can exceed the wall clock).
4. Divide by the window's token count → ms/token; if kernel time ≈ step
   time, the table IS the optimization plan.

Worked example (GLM-5.3-Flash, 2×GPU, offload, decode 9.9 tok/s):

```
34.8 %  708,500 launches  vectorized_elementwise_kernel   <- the actual bound
10.0 %   42,000           MoE W4A16 GEMM
 8.9 %   83,160           router/top-k (sort-based)
 6.5 %  133,920           hyper-connection pre/post kernels
 1.05 %   20,664          <the long-suspected expert gather>
```

No amount of link arithmetic would have produced those two conclusions: the
suspect was 1 %, and the mass was pointwise glue from an uncompiled trunk —
whose own boot log names the cause (`FULL_DECODE_ONLY` override). It also
predicted a negative result in advance (spec decode cannot help a shape whose
per-token cost scales with the token count) which matched an unexplained flat
MTP measurement.

## 4. Telemetry without benchmarking (live hosts)

When benching is forbidden (production serving), mine the runtime's own
per-request telemetry — it measures the real workload and costs nothing.

- llama.cpp (root unit, `-lv 3`): `sudo journalctl -u <unit> --since "-3h"
  --no-pager` → `slot print_timing` lines (prompt eval, eval, total, `graphs
  reused`, `draft acceptance … mean len`, `n_gen = N, tg = X t/s, tg_3s = …`).
- halogen (rootless quadlet): `journalctl --user -u <unit>` (**never sudo** —
  per-user storage) → `serve_api: mtp 28 tok in 0.66s = 42.45 t/s | 16
  rounds, commit 1.75/round | prompt 58, prefill 0.92s | detok 24us/tok`.
- Read the envelope, never one sample: short-prompt `prompt eval` is
  overhead-dominated (57 tok @ 168 t/s) — quote the longest available (1106
  tok @ 1013 t/s); decode and acceptance are content-dependent (0.46–0.76
  measured on one unchanged build); `graphs reused > 0` / `selected slot by
  LCP similarity` prove prefix-cache reuse.
- **Attribute PCIe without touching the model:** background `nvidia-smi dmon
  -s t -c 16 -o T`, ONE ordinary `max_tokens=200` request, `wait` at the end
  (without it ssh closes and the client dies — the journal shows `W srv stop:
  cancel task` and NO print_timing while curl still reports plausible
  status). Measured: peak ~230 MB/s against a ~7,900 MB/s link = ~3 %, 0 at
  idle — the sampled-logits stream, not the transport, is decode traffic on
  that shape.
- One `max_tokens=200` request is production traffic and fine; anything that
  pins the card is a bench → stop-and-mask first. Check WHICH instance you
  are reading (`systemctl status | head -12`; task ids jump across
  restarts). The engine's own ledger (`KV self size`, `n_slots`,
  `n_ctx_slot`) outranks your model of it.

## 5. The fork's data path (before blaming the link)

Offload engines pick between DMA copy-in and read-through UVA dereference
inside the GEMM. Grep the installed package for the LRU/offload module and
read the BRANCH CONDITION, not just the env names. A token-count threshold
decides the path, and it interacts with spec decoding: an MTP step is k+1
tokens, so the step can silently cross the threshold onto the slow path as
draft depth grows. Check the threshold's premise: a default tuned at
12.4 MiB/expert does not transfer to 2.344 MiB/expert, where copy-in can be
several times faster. TunableOp ghost-skip: `CLAV_TUNABLEOP_SWEEP=1` alone
does NOTHING under expert offload (`CLAV_TUNABLEOP_WITH_OFFLOAD=1` required);
check for the skip line before concluding autotuning ran. Gather-geometry
knobs read at import time → each arm is a full reload.

## 6. RAM-bandwidth-bound MoE ceiling (before recommending a quant)

```
routed experts/token = top_k × n_layers
bytes/token          = routed_params × bytes_per_param + shared_expert_bytes
ceiling (tok/s)      = measured_bandwidth / bytes_per_token
```

Measure the HOST's real bandwidth, never assume DIMM ratings: 4-DIMM AM5
boards downclock to DDR5-3600 regardless of 5600 sticks (two large DIMMs beat
four small). Single-threaded reads under-report dual-channel ~4x — use the
multi-threaded plateau of a checksumming reader (`scripts` pattern:
`/tmp/bw.c`, 1/2/4/8/16 threads). Worked example (DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash):
6×40 experts × 35.4M params = 8.5B params/token; at 3 bpw + 0.53 GB shared =
**3.7 GB/token** → 42 GB/s ⇒ **11.3 tok/s ceiling**. Sanity anchors: H100
NVL + CPU offload 226 GB ⇒ 5.8–9.0 tok/s; 2×3090 + 768 GB DDR4 ⇒ 12.2.
CPU compute rarely binds below 4 bpw (~5.3 flops/byte ⇒ ~223 GFLOPS at 42
GB/s); PCIe expert STREAMING is worse than CPU compute (Gen5 x8 ~22.7 GB/s
effective < half of RAM); prefill reads the union of a batch's experts
(prefill ≈ bandwidth / total_expert_bytes × ubatch). A quant that fits only
by ignoring the Engram table does not fit (Engram = sparse n-gram lookup,
NVMe-tolerant; the routed experts are not). An iGPU GTT aperture is an ALIAS
of the same RAM, not extra memory.

## 7. IBS model-access attribution (AMD CPUs)

Real CPU access patterns for mmap'd weights, live, no stop (established on
frank-archon, 2026-09-26, ~2.7M attributed samples in 75 s). Reference:
`scripts/frank-archon-expert-activity.py` (self-contained dump + sample +
analyze; `--analyze-only`).

1. GGUF header-only scan (ms for a 50 GiB part) → tensor extents. **Extents
   from CONSECUTIVE offsets, never a type-size table** — a wrong per-element
   size silently under-covers every tensor and dumps tail samples into a junk
   bucket (first run lost 59 % of expert samples; a uniform gap/exps ratio
   ~1.4 across parts is the tell). Data start = `(tell + 31) & ~31`.
2. `/proc/<pid>/maps` VMAs (7-group regex; pgoff = group 4, path = group 7)
   matched against part files; multi-VMA per part is normal.
3. `sudo perf record -e ibs_op// -c 50000 --data -o out.perf -p <pid> --
   sleep <dur>` WHILE a mixed workload runs (idle perf numbers mean nothing).
   `sudo perf script -i out.perf -F addr` for addresses.
4. Attribute: bisect VMAs, `foff = pgoff + (addr − vma_start)`, bisect tensor
   starts; per-expert index = `int(lo / (span / N_EXPERTS))` (expert-major
   rows).
5. Verify before believing histograms: gap ≈ 0, every tensor-bearing part
   nonzero, and MoE blocks should be FLAT by construction (top-k fires every
   block every token) — a non-flat block histogram means mis-attribution
   first. Established law: expert routing is per-block flat, per-EXPERT
   skewed.

## 8. Prefix-cache-aware routing (multi-replica serving)

Measure with a **sequential-turn client**, not only a batch benchmark — a
batch of distinct prompts parallelises prefill across replicas and hides the
problem. The two failure modes: round-robin loses every other cache hit
(90k-token contexts: warm-turn TTFT 2676 ms round-robin vs 1096 ms pinned);
pinning-everything loses a card (16 requests: 18.6 s spread vs 30.1 s
pinned). **The rule that gets both: route by request shape** — a request
carrying more than one message is a continuation (agent loop re-sending its
context) → pin to the replica that served that prefix; anything else → spread
with a COUNTER, not a prefix hash. Add failover: demote a replica on
connection failure and retry on a live one BEFORE writing anything to the
client (safe pre-stream; never retry after streaming started).

The wall no policy fixes: **a running sequence and its cached prefix draw on
the SAME pool.** Three concurrent 50–80k families against 122,636 tokens/card
thrash under every placement and admission policy tried (counter placement,
load-balanced placement, one-large-request-per-card admission, both chunk
directions — the last COSTS KV in both directions). When the working set
exceeds aggregate KV, say so: the levers are capacity, fewer concurrent
large contexts, or a different platform. Traps: a lifetime hit-rate counter
is not a per-request verdict (probe directly: same prompt twice to an idle
replica — 22.3 s cold → 1.4 s warm); salt corpora; record sample sizes;
`vllm bench serve` needs `--tokenizer <local path>`; verify metric names
against the live endpoint before dashboards. Test shape: drive the routing
function directly with synthetic bodies (stdlib-only policy module);
conversation identity is the FIRST N KiB of prompt — a shorter tested prefix
hashes differently per turn and pinning silently never happens.

## Related

- [[LLM Bench Windows and Measurement]] — the window discipline and usage-counter law
- [[PCIe Link and Atomics]] — link probing and the streaming-vs-compute ceiling
- [[RDNA4 MoE Expert Offload VRAM Budget]] — the plan behind duty-cycle terms
- [[vLLM Porting and Compile Triage]] — the compile fix for the pointwise-glue bound