fix: basicauth double-prefix render; open-webui off slirp4netns

basicauth (2026-08-22 incident):
- the Caddyfile template carried its own $2a$14$ prefix and deploy.sh
  substituted the full hash (prefix included), rendering an invalid
  double-prefixed hash. Every basicauth vhost rejected every password
  with 401 and Caddy logged nothing.
- template is now a bare REPLACE_WITH_HASH token; tests pin the render
  contract (no prefix in template; rendered line is exactly 'dank <hash>').

open-webui (2026-08-22 incident):
- its slirp4netns helper process died, leaving the container running
  with only 'lo' in its netns: port 3005 accepted TCP and reset every
  request, so chat served empty responses for ~2 days, unlogged.
- move to a pinned bridge network (systemd-open-webui, 10.89.3.0/24,
  gw 10.89.3.1) — no per-container helper to die.
- LLM endpoint reached via the gateway (host.containers.internal is
  slirp-only): OPENAI_API_BASE_URL=http://10.89.3.1:52625.
- add a quadlet healthcheck: /health (app) + non-loopback interface
  (network liveness; the dead-tap state leaves only 'lo').
- deploy script now copies the .network file too.
- docs updated (OpenWebUI History section, Caddy basic-auth contract).
This commit is contained in:
Frank
2026-08-22 13:07:43 -07:00
parent 5c9ade4e7a
commit da68b5ce1a
9 changed files with 129 additions and 27 deletions
+8 -8
View File
@@ -43,7 +43,7 @@
# --- Homepage (password protected) ---
dankclaw.franksdank.cloud {
basicauth {
dank $2a$14$REPLACE_WITH_HASH
dank REPLACE_WITH_HASH
}
root * /srv/homepage
file_server
@@ -61,7 +61,7 @@ dankserver.franksdank.cloud {
# --- SearXNG (quadlet; behind the Gluetun tunnel, published 8081) ---
search.franksdank.cloud {
basicauth {
dank $2a$14$REPLACE_WITH_HASH
dank REPLACE_WITH_HASH
}
reverse_proxy 192.168.0.143:8081
}
@@ -74,7 +74,7 @@ comfyui.franksdank.cloud {
# --- OpenWebUI (quadlet on slirp4netns; published 3005) ---
chat.franksdank.cloud {
basicauth {
dank $2a$14$REPLACE_WITH_HASH
dank REPLACE_WITH_HASH
}
reverse_proxy 192.168.0.143:3005
}
@@ -82,7 +82,7 @@ chat.franksdank.cloud {
# --- Hermes ---
hermes.franksdank.cloud {
basicauth {
dank $2a$14$REPLACE_WITH_HASH
dank REPLACE_WITH_HASH
}
reverse_proxy hermes:8090
}
@@ -95,7 +95,7 @@ gitea.franksdank.cloud {
# --- Grafana ---
grafana.franksdank.cloud {
basicauth {
dank $2a$14$REPLACE_WITH_HASH
dank REPLACE_WITH_HASH
}
reverse_proxy grafana:3000
}
@@ -103,7 +103,7 @@ grafana.franksdank.cloud {
# --- Prometheus ---
prometheus.franksdank.cloud {
basicauth {
dank $2a$14$REPLACE_WITH_HASH
dank REPLACE_WITH_HASH
}
reverse_proxy prometheus:9090
}
@@ -138,7 +138,7 @@ books.franksdank.cloud {
# --- RomM ---
romm.franksdank.cloud {
basicauth {
dank $2a$14$REPLACE_WITH_HASH
dank REPLACE_WITH_HASH
}
reverse_proxy 192.168.0.235:8085
}
@@ -146,7 +146,7 @@ romm.franksdank.cloud {
# --- Copyparty ---
files.franksdank.cloud {
basicauth {
dank $2a$14$REPLACE_WITH_HASH
dank REPLACE_WITH_HASH
}
reverse_proxy 192.168.0.235:3923
}
@@ -5,10 +5,18 @@
#
# Chat UI for the LLM fleet. It runs on the CPU image (dankclaw is CPU-only, so
# the :cuda image would waste a large pull for a GPU it cannot use) and points
# its OpenAI connection at the live vLLM backend on this host
# (host.containers.internal:52625, model frank-default-large). It is isolated on
# slirp4netns and publishes 3005 (3000 is Gitea's HTTP port). Data persists under
# its OpenAI connection at the live vLLM backend on this host via the bridge
# gateway (10.89.3.1:52625, model frank-default-large). It publishes 3005
# (3000 is Gitea's HTTP port). Data persists under
# /home/dank/Containers/open-webui/data. See docs/Dankclaw/OpenWebUI.md.
#
# Network history (2026-08-22): this unit used Network=slirp4netns. When the
# slirp4netns helper process died, the container kept running but lost its tap
# interface: a zombie that accepted TCP and reset every request, and chat
# served empty responses for ~2 days with no error anywhere. It now runs on a
# pinned bridge network (open-webui.network), which has no per-container
# helper to die. The healthcheck probes /health (app liveness) and requires a
# non-loopback interface (network liveness).
[Unit]
Description=open-webui chat UI container
@@ -16,14 +24,22 @@ After=network.target
[Container]
ContainerName=open-webui
Network=slirp4netns
Network=open-webui.network
Image=ghcr.io/open-webui/open-webui:main
PublishPort=3005:8080
Environment=OPENAI_API_BASE_URL=http://host.containers.internal:52625
Environment=OPENAI_API_BASE_URL=http://10.89.3.1:52625
Environment=ANONYMIZED_TELEMETRY=False
Environment=DO_NOT_TRACK=True
Volume=/home/dank/Containers/open-webui/data:/app/backend/data
# App liveness (/health) AND network liveness (a non-loopback interface must
# exist; a dead tap leaves only "lo" behind).
HealthCmd=CMD-SHELL python -c 'import os,urllib.request,sys; urllib.request.urlopen("http://127.0.0.1:8080/health",timeout=5).read(); sys.exit(0 if any(i!="lo" for i in os.listdir("/sys/class/net")) else 1)'
HealthInterval=30s
HealthTimeout=10s
HealthRetries=3
HealthStartPeriod=300s
[Service]
TimeoutStartSec=900
Restart=always
@@ -0,0 +1,29 @@
# Quadlet network: private bridge for open-webui (rootless).
#
# Install path on dankclaw: ~/.config/containers/systemd/open-webui.network
# Unit name: open-webui-network.service (podman network name: systemd-open-webui)
#
# Why a bridge instead of slirp4netns (2026-08-22 incident):
# slirp4netns runs a user-space helper process per container. When that
# helper died, the container kept running but lost its tap interface,
# becoming a zombie that accepted TCP and reset every request. chat
# served empty responses for ~2 days and nothing logged an error.
# A kernel bridge has no per-container helper, so the failure mode
# cannot occur.
#
# The subnet is pinned so the gateway IP is deterministic: the LLM
# backend (llama-server :52625, bound 0.0.0.0 on the host) is reached
# from the container via the gateway. host.containers.internal is a
# slirp4netns-only name and does not resolve on a bridge.
#
# Subnet registry on dankclaw (rootless):
# 10.88.0.0/16 default "podman" bridge
# 10.89.0.0/24 gitea (systemd-gitea)
# 10.89.1.0/24 compose stack (dankclaw_default)
# 10.89.2.0/24 searxng (systemd-searxng)
# 10.89.3.0/24 open-webui (systemd-open-webui) <- this file
[Network]
Driver=bridge
Subnet=10.89.3.0/24
Gateway=10.89.3.1
+13 -4
View File
@@ -11,8 +11,8 @@ OpenWebUI is a self-hosted chat interface for LLMs. It connects to OpenAI-compat
| Image | `ghcr.io/open-webui/open-webui:main` (CPU build; Dankclaw is CPU-only) |
| Port | 3005 (host) → 8080 (container). Port 3000 is Gitea's HTTP, so it is not usable. |
| Data volume | `/home/dank/Containers/open-webui/data` → `/app/backend/data` |
| Default backend | vLLM on Dankclaw `:52625` = `frank-default-large` (via `host.containers.internal:52625`) |
| Network | `slirp4netns` (isolated) |
| Default backend | vLLM on Dankclaw `:52625` = `frank-default-large` (via bridge gateway `10.89.3.1:52625`) |
| Network | Pinned bridge `systemd-open-webui` (`10.89.3.0/24`, gateway `10.89.3.1`) — see [History](#history) |
| Persistence | Quadlet unit `open-webui.service`; `[Install] WantedBy=default.target` |
| Deploy | `scripts/deploy-open-webui-quadlet.sh dankclaw` |
@@ -43,7 +43,12 @@ The data dir holds the database, RAG indexes, and uploads. The deploy script cre
## Healthcheck
OpenWebUI responds on `/health` with 200. Probe it at `http://dankclaw:3005/health`.
The quadlet carries a built-in healthcheck (30s interval, 3 retries, 300s start period). It checks two things from inside the container:
1. **App liveness** — `GET http://127.0.0.1:8080/health` returns 200 (`{"status":true}`).
2. **Network liveness** — a non-loopback interface exists in `/sys/class/net`. The dead-tap zombie state (History) leaves only `lo` behind, and this is the check that catches it.
`podman ps` shows the container as `unhealthy` if either fails. Probe manually at `http://dankclaw:3005/health`.
## Retired instances
@@ -56,7 +61,11 @@ OpenWebUI responds on `/health` with 200. Probe it at `http://dankclaw:3005/heal
- Use the non-CUDA image on this CPU-only host.
- The default admin account is created on first login; secure it immediately.
- If the backend is loading (3–8 minute model load), OpenWebUI shows connection errors until the model is ready.
- `host.containers.internal` reaches only the podman host. To reach the Dankserver backend, use the LAN address `192.168.0.235:7770`.
- The LLM is reached via the bridge gateway `10.89.3.1`, not `host.containers.internal` (that name is slirp4netns-only and does not resolve on a bridge). To reach the Dankserver backend, use the LAN address `192.168.0.235:7770`.
## History
- **2026-08-22 — slirp4netns → pinned bridge.** The unit ran on `Network=slirp4netns`. The slirp4netns helper process died (no OOM, no kill entry, no crash log found), and the container kept running with only `lo` in its netns: published port 3005 accepted TCP and reset every request, so chat served empty responses for ~2 days. Nothing logged an error. Moving to a kernel bridge removes the per-container helper entirely, and the healthcheck's interface check makes the zombie state visible if it ever returns.
## See Also
+5 -2
View File
@@ -50,17 +50,19 @@ The bare-IP catch-all `:80` 302-redirects to `https://dankclaw.franksdank.cloud/
## Basic auth
Generate a bcrypt hash, then reference it:
The Caddyfile in git carries a **bare** placeholder; deploy.sh substitutes the **full** hash from the host `.env` (`CADDY_BASICAUTH_HASH`):
```
chat.franksdank.cloud {
basicauth {
dank $2a$14$xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
dank REPLACE_WITH_HASH
}
reverse_proxy 192.168.0.143:3005
}
```
After rendering, the line reads `dank $2a$14$xxxx…` (one complete hash). Do not put a `$2a$14$` prefix in the template: it would render a double-prefixed, invalid hash (2026-08-22 incident — every basicauth vhost returned 401 for every password). `tests/deployment_flow.bats` pins the render contract.
The homepage also uses basic auth; see [[Homepage]].
## Operations
@@ -75,6 +77,7 @@ Certificates and ACME state live in the caddy data volume. Back it up with the s
## Gotchas
- The basicauth template must stay a bare `REPLACE_WITH_HASH` token (no `$2a$14$` prefix) — the rendered value is the complete hash. A double prefix silently rejects every password with 401; no Caddy error is logged.
- A new vhost needs three things: a dnsmasq `addn-hosts` line, a Porkbun A record, and the Caddyfile block. See [[LAN-DNS]].
- The G36 has no NAT loopback, so LAN clients must resolve the name to the LAN IP. That is the dnsmasq role in [[LAN-DNS]].
- Caddy serves HTTPS on 443 and HTTP on 80 (redirects). The router needs no 80/443 port forward for LAN use.
+3 -2
View File
@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@
# open-webui is boot-persistent via Quadlet (see AGENTS.md). This script:
# 1. Pushes main to origin
# 2. Pulls the repo on the target
# 3. Creates the data dir and copies the unit into ~/.config/containers/systemd/
# 3. Creates the data dir and copies the unit + network into ~/.config/containers/systemd/
# 4. daemon-reloads and starts open-webui (first run pulls the image)
#
# It is idempotent: it stops any running unit and removes any container with the
@@ -75,9 +75,10 @@ podman rm -f open-webui 2>/dev/null || true
echo ' Creating the data dir (preserved across reruns)...'
mkdir -p '${DATA_DIR}'
echo ' Copying the quadlet unit into ~/.config/containers/systemd/ ...'
echo ' Copying the quadlet unit + network into ~/.config/containers/systemd/ ...'
mkdir -p ~/.config/containers/systemd
cp ${QDIR}/open-webui.container ~/.config/containers/systemd/
cp ${QDIR}/open-webui.network ~/.config/containers/systemd/
echo ' daemon-reload (generates the unit)...'
# Quadlet units are generator-managed: systemctl enable fails on them. The
+13
View File
@@ -49,6 +49,19 @@ CADDYFILE="$REPO_ROOT/dankclaw/Caddyfile"
grep -q 'REPLACE_WITH_HASH' "$CADDYFILE"
}
@test "the basicauth placeholder is a bare token (no bcrypt prefix in the template)" {
# Regression (2026-08-22): the template line was
# dank $2a$14$REPLACE_WITH_HASH
# and deploy.sh substitutes the FULL hash (prefix included), so the
# rendered line became an invalid double-prefixed hash and every
# basicauth vhost rejected every password with 401.
if grep -qE '\$2[abxy]\$[0-9]+\$REPLACE_WITH_HASH' "$CADDYFILE"; then
echo "Caddyfile: bcrypt prefix before REPLACE_WITH_HASH (double-prefix regression)"
return 1
fi
grep -qE 'dank REPLACE_WITH_HASH' "$CADDYFILE"
}
@test "compose no longer defines the quadlet-replaced services" {
# gitea, its postgres, and open-webui run as boot-persistent quadlets on
# dankclaw (see dankclaw/gitea/quadlet, dankclaw/open-webui/quadlet).
+5
View File
@@ -44,4 +44,9 @@ load helpers
[ -n "$rendered" ]
[[ "$rendered" == *"${hash}"* ]]
! grep -q 'REPLACE_WITH_HASH' <<< "$rendered"
# The rendered line must be exactly "dank <hash>". A template that keeps
# its own $2a$14$ prefix renders an invalid double-prefixed hash and
# every basicauth vhost returns 401 (2026-08-22 incident).
grep -qF "dank ${hash}" <<< "$rendered"
! grep -qF '$2a$14$$2a$14$' <<< "$rendered"
}
+32 -6
View File
@@ -24,9 +24,33 @@ QDIR="$REPO_ROOT/dankclaw/open-webui/quadlet"
return 0
}
@test "open-webui is isolated on slirp4netns" {
grep -qE '^Network=slirp4netns' "$QDIR/open-webui.container" \
|| { echo "open-webui.container must set Network=slirp4netns"; return 1; }
@test "open-webui is on a private bridge network (not slirp4netns)" {
# slirp4netns runs a user-space helper per container. When the helper
# dies, the container keeps running but loses its tap interface: a
# zombie that accepts TCP and resets every request (2026-08-22: chat
# returned empty responses for ~2 days). A bridge network has no
# per-container helper, so the failure mode cannot occur.
grep -qE '^Network=open-webui\.network' "$QDIR/open-webui.container" \
|| { echo "open-webui.container must set Network=open-webui.network"; return 1; }
! grep -qE '^Network=slirp4netns' "$QDIR/open-webui.container"
[ -f "$QDIR/open-webui.network" ]
}
@test "open-webui network pins a deterministic subnet and gateway" {
# The LLM endpoint is reached via the bridge gateway, so the subnet
# must be pinned (an auto-assigned subnet is not a promise).
grep -qE '^Subnet=10\.89\.3\.0/24' "$QDIR/open-webui.network"
grep -qE '^Gateway=10\.89\.3\.1' "$QDIR/open-webui.network"
}
@test "open-webui has a healthcheck that sees the app AND the network" {
# The /health probe catches app hangs; the non-loopback interface check
# catches the dead-tap zombie state (only "lo" left in the netns).
grep -qE '^HealthCmd=CMD-SHELL .*/health.*' "$QDIR/open-webui.container"
grep -qE '^HealthCmd=.*sys/class/net.*' "$QDIR/open-webui.container"
grep -qE '^HealthInterval=30s' "$QDIR/open-webui.container"
grep -qE '^HealthRetries=3' "$QDIR/open-webui.container"
grep -qE '^HealthStartPeriod=' "$QDIR/open-webui.container"
}
@test "open-webui publishes 3005:8080 (a free port; 3000 is Gitea)" {
@@ -34,10 +58,12 @@ QDIR="$REPO_ROOT/dankclaw/open-webui/quadlet"
|| { echo "open-webui.container must publish 3005:8080"; return 1; }
}
@test "open-webui points its LLM at the live vLLM backend (52625)" {
grep -qE '^Environment=OPENAI_API_BASE_URL=http://host\.containers\.internal:52625' \
@test "open-webui points its LLM at the live vLLM backend (52625) via the bridge gateway" {
# host.containers.internal is a slirp4netns-only name. On the bridge,
# the host's 0.0.0.0-bound services are reached via the gateway IP.
grep -qE '^Environment=OPENAI_API_BASE_URL=http://10\.89\.3\.1:52625' \
"$QDIR/open-webui.container" \
|| { echo "open-webui.container must set OPENAI_API_BASE_URL to the vLLM on 52625"; return 1; }
|| { echo "open-webui.container must set OPENAI_API_BASE_URL to the vLLM on the bridge gateway 10.89.3.1:52625"; return 1; }
}
@test "open-webui persists its data under /home/dank/Containers/open-webui/data" {