Comments/docs only - no functional change. The live boot of c769ff2 reported:
GPU KV cache size: 398,658 tokens,
Maximum concurrency for 200,704 tokens per request: 1.99x
expert cache space 14.87 GiB / 6,496 slots of 2.344 MiB
The arena prediction (6,496) landed exactly; the concurrency prediction (2.04x)
did not, because the per-token KV price is SHAPE-DEPENDENT: 7,701 B/token at
MAXLEN 262144 (6.1e9 -> 792,069 tokens) but 7,892 at 200704 (3.146e9 ->
398,658). Never extrapolate a concurrency figure across geometries.
Also smoke-verified: three concurrent 67-token requests answered in parallel,
~4.1 s each - the 3 slots are real, and the pool admits 2 full-length.
Re-applies the desired shape incrementally on the proven-good fp8 3x262144
base, after bisecting why the first attempt (30904ba) crash-looped.
Root cause: `--max-num-seqs 2` cannot compile on this model. AOT
build_guards(strict_error=True) inside profile_run -> _dummy_run specializes
`query_start_loc`'s width to SEQS + 1 (3 at SEQS 2, 4 at SEQS 3) and the
ConstraintViolationError kills engine init ~7 min in. MNBT is orthogonal:
SEQS 2 failed at MNBT 1024 AND 2048; SEQS 3 passed at both. KV dtype was a
red herring. Measured by four single-variable boot probes.
Arena lever measured: the expert arena is sized from `max_model_len` via the
registry-priced KV reserve (9190 B/token x max_model_len), NOT from
--kv-cache-memory-bytes. 262144 -> 14.30 GiB / 6,248 slots; 200704 ->
14.87 GiB / 6,496 slots. The 6.1e9 -> 3.15e9 pool cut bought zero arena and
is a runtime-headroom lever.
Shape: MAXLEN 200704, SEQS 3 (unchanged - the only slot count that compiles),
KV_BYTES 3.15e9/rank = 2.04x full-length concurrency at 7,701 B/token fp8,
MNBT 1024, gather 32x64, no spec decode, no prefetch, no precise-memory.
The 2 x 200704 fp8 / MNBT 1024 shape (30904ba) crash-loops at boot: the
engine dies in determine_available_memory -> profile_run -> _dummy_run with
the SAME torch.compile dynamo constraint that killed the bf16 2 x 262144
shape on 2026-10-01:
RuntimeError: Worker failed with error 'Constraints violated
(L['query_start_loc'].size()[0])! You marked it as dynamic but your code
specialized it to be a constant (3)'
Not an OOM. Restoring the last shape measured serving (fp8 3 x 262144 /
KV 6.1e9 / MNBT 2048 / arena 6,248) so the endpoint serves again; the
desired edits are re-applied one at a time from this base.
The 2026-10-01 bf16 shape (2 x 262144, --expert-precise-memory)
crash-looped at graph capture — the arena is DEVICE-resident and that
shape had 0.13 GiB to spare. The plain bf16 2 x 262144 also did not stay
up: 0 bytes free at runtime, and a real client request (995-token prompt,
max_tokens=261149) killed the worker with .
The correction is a pool cut, not a downgrade. FP8 KV (7,701 B/token),
two 200704 windows (401,408 tokens -> 3.091e9 B floor, pinned 3.15e9),
MNBT 1024. The fork's expert planner sizes the arena AFTER the KV
override, so the ~2.95 GiB/rank reclaimed becomes arena: ~7,500 slots
vs 6,248. Two contexts at 200704 is a capacity contract, not a
throughput one (2-way concurrency summed BELOW parity at 4064 ctx), so
the slot buys the VRAM headroom long generations need.
Refs [[dankserver-qwen38-fp8-expert-offload-tuning]].
- scripts/frank-primary.env: MAXLEN 200704, SEQS 2, KV_BYTES 3.15e9,
MNBT 1024, rewritten shape comment
- scripts/serve-frank-primary.sh: header comment updated
- tests/frank_primary_unit.bats: assertions updated, new seam pins the
arena-floor pool law (the pool must move with a context change or the
reduction buys nothing)
- docs + AGENTS.md: fleet topology and deployed shape corrected
Benchmark entrypoint: bash autoresearch.sh
Goal: Make frank-primary faster: raise decode tok/s on the tcclaviger vLLM endpoint (dankserver :7770, Qwen3.8-Flash-Next-Uncensored-FP8, 2x R9700, automatic tiered-expert offload). Context size may be altered (MAXLEN/SEQS/KV_BYTES and friends); quantization may NOT be altered (the 131-shard FP8 payload and the digest-pinned image are frozen).
Runbook, both indexes, AGENTS.md (topology row, endpoint section, three new
Key Lessons, one stale SGLang label in the bench list) and the bundle log now
describe the deployed shape: pool 540,672, 180,224 tokens per conversation,
f16 K + q8_0 V, mmproj vision, 21,684 used / 2,441 free of 24,576 MiB, 106.8
tok/s decode, 3,814 t/s prefill.
The claims that mattered:
- three contexts buy 180,224 tokens per conversation, not the native 262,144,
and a longer prompt is a hard 400 - so models.yml contextWindow is 180224
and frank-primary's 183,501-token compaction request no longer fits here
(forward pointer added to the retired SGLang runbook, which asserted it)
- the vision tower bills ~1.4 GiB for a 918 MB file, established by subtracting
two measured boots, not by a formula
- /v1/chat/completions ignores the legacy top-level 'images' field: the model
invents a color; only the image_url content part reaches it
Measured after the first 3-slot deploy: 3 x 196,608 booted (n_slots=3,
n_ctx_slot=196608, multimodal loaded) but used 22,972/24,576 MiB - 1,153 MiB
free, outside the 2-3 GiB band. The two measurements now recorded in
frank-small.env price the vision tower at ~1.4 GiB (non-KV 7,390 -> 8,859
MiB), so the pool drops 49,152 tokens (16,384/slot, 1,176 MiB) to land ~2.7
GiB free. The bats budget gate is recalibrated to the measured 9 GiB non-KV
cost, which now rejects the 3 x 196,608 shape instead of blessing it.
CTX_SIZE 589824 / PARALLEL 3 -> three independent 196,608-token conversations
(a mamba hybrid cannot share one KV cache, so per-slot window = pool/slots;
3 x 262,144 would need 18.4 GiB of KV alone and busts the card).
Vision comes back via bartowski's mmproj-MiMo-V2.6-Distill-Qwen-9B-f16.gguf
(918,166,048 B, sha256 ff348f31..., fetched + verified by
scripts/download-frank-small.sh): the Q5_K_M GGUF ships no v.* tensors, so
--mmproj IS the image path. MMPROJ_FILE without a colon default so an explicit
empty value is a real text-only opt-out, and the deployer now gates on the
projector exactly as the serve script does.
Budget is measured, not guessed: the 2 x 262,144 shape used 20,190/24,576 MiB,
which prices non-KV cost at 7,390 MiB. Three slots + projector land near
22.5 GiB, i.e. ~2 GiB spare - the bottom of the requested band, to be
confirmed by measurement and laddered if it lands outside 2-3 GiB.
Staged 59 GiB of retired LLM payloads on Dankclaw to
~dank/.AGENTTRASH/20261002-retired-llm-payloads/ (vLLM MiMo BF16, Qwen3.5-9B
MTP source, both DFlash dirs, Gemma4-12B-QAT, SGLang MiMo INT8) and corrected
every doc claim about what is on disk: gufo's rollback pair (Q4_K_XL weights +
the Q8_K_XL DFlash2 drafter) and frank-small's Q6_K stay in place, so the
rollback paths in the tags' env files still resolve. The vLLM-era frank-large
fetch trio moves to old/ with its runtime; runbook links updated.
The repo's highest-quality rung is ftype 115: 311 tensors of
GGML_TYPE_Q8_0_ROCMFPX, a type only the ROCmFPX fork reads, so the runtime
moves from gufo to scripts/build-rocmfpx.sh's pinned fork build (36e9acd) —
the first build on this host measured to load this file without the
2026-08-25 set_rows segfault. One session at the native 262,144 window, f16
KV (64 KiB/token, 16 GiB), the repo's Q4_0 MTP head drafting 4 tokens, plus
the bundled BF16 projector so the endpoint has vision again.
The serve script now honors caller environment overrides over the env file
(a plain source let the file win, which made single-run overrides no-ops) and
defaults apply only when a value is unset, so an explicit LLAMA_BIN='' is the
error it reads as.
One quant step down from Q6_K on the same CUDA build and the same shape:
2 x 262,144 with K f16 + V q8_0. The 0.86 GiB freed from the weights is
headroom, not a new window — the native 262,144 cap is already reached,
and f16 V would still cost 3.96 GiB more than the pool can carry.
Live battery green after deploy #3: alias, reasoning split into
`reasoning`, tool_calls, /metrics acceptance pos0 69% pos1 44% - the
cross-model MTP head performs as measured in the bench window.
The first crash-looping boot (51 restarts): serve received the host path
/home/dank/models/... but the models tree is mounted at /models inside the
container, so transformers failed 'Repo id must be in the form
namespace/repo_name' before the engine even built. Same conversion the spec
draft already used. Pinned by bats. Root docs index links the new runbook
(seam required it) and the work log records the crash-loop plus the 52 G
payload reclaim.
The 2026-10-01 first deploy refused /home/dank/models/Qwen3.5-9B because
the handler checked for a single model.safetensors (the dflash layout);
the Qwen3.5-9B MTP head ships 4 shards behind model.safetensors.index.json.
Same dual-layout acceptance as the serve script, now mirrored and gated by
the seam. The gate fired before the stop, so the live gufo unit was never
touched (health 200 throughout).
Engine: digest-pinned docker.io/kyuz0/vllm-therock-gfx1151 (vLLM 0.30,
TheRock ROCm 10, Triton GDN kernels); the serve script gates the image by
REPO DIGEST, the payload (config + index + exact shard count), the spec
draft (BOTH weight layouts: single model.safetensors for dflash, sharded
index for the Qwen3.5-9B MTP head), and whole /dev/dri, sweeps the bench
identity vllm-mimo, then exec podman wait so a container death trips
Restart=always. Shape: 4 x 262144 at util 0.45 (KV grows only on the 8
full-attention layers), MTP 2 draft tokens.
Measured 2026-10-01 window (frank-large stopped): base 13.1 t/s decode
(~94% of the LPDDR5x BF16 roof), DFlash-8 17.4, MTP-2 19.8 with 71%/44%
per-position acceptance - the cross-model head works because vLLM reads the
draft from a separate path while MiMo ships zero mtp.* tensors. Spec arms
do not preserve greedy bf16 text (batched-verify reduction order).
The seam was rewritten around the new laws (18 tests): unit self-healing,
digest gating, engine wiring, the measured spec table, the retired gufo
gates, the deployer MainPID check. frank_small port test follows the
PORT -> FRANK_LARGE_PUBLISH rename. Rollback: tag frank-large-gufo-q4kxl-20261001.
All three verify every file by byte count + Hub LFS sha256, use -f (a bare
curl -o reports success on a 403 error body), support --verify-only, and
never put a token on the command line. Payloads are on Dankclaw and verified
against these manifests.
bf16 at 2 x 262144 fails with and without --expert-precise-memory. The real
error (captured from the journal this time, container fixed via journald
rather than podman logs):
RuntimeError: Worker failed with error 'Constraints violated
(L['query_start_loc'].size()[0])! You marked it as dynamic but your code
specialized it to be a constant (3)'
- a torch.compile/dynamo dynamic-shape violation, NOT an OOM. Ruled out a
stale compile cache: ~/.cache/vllm holds only modelinfos (16K) and each
podman run gets a fresh container filesystem.
The deltas from the last shape measured serving (fp8 3 x 262144 / MNBT 2048 /
792,069 tokens / 3.02x / arena 6,248) are KV dtype (fp8 -> bf16) and SEQS
(3 -> 2). Restoring the known-good shape; bisect bf16 vs SEQS in a window,
with --enforce-eager as the bypass.
NRestarts climbed to 3, each attempt ~6.7 min then 'Deactivated successfully'
(API server drains after an EngineCore fatal error; Restart=always turned the
silent death into a visible loop). The arena is device-resident, so the budget
decides it: weights 6.28 + pool 6.80 (bf16 2 x 262144) + graphs 0.55 + arena
16.65 (precise overhead 5.25) + non-torch 1.45 = 31.73 of 31.86 GiB -> ~0.13
GiB free at boot, and graph capture is what allocates transiently.
Dropping the flag restores the 7.60 GiB default overhead: arena 14.31 GiB,
total ~29.4 GiB, ~2.4 GiB free. bf16 2 x 262144 (Frank's KV change) stays.
The serve script keeps the opt-in flag; the seam now asserts it is ABSENT.
Frank's call. Payload: ajgazin's abliterated Swift-1.5 UD-Q8_K_XL (29.3 GiB,
SWIFT OPEN LICENSE) -> unsloth/Qwen3.8-27B-GGUF UD-Q4_K_XL (16.35 GiB,
sha256 3f227079...b01e, vanilla/Apache-2.0). NOTE: the endpoint is no longer
uncensored — that was one of the reasons for the Swift payload on 2026-09-28.
New fetcher scripts/download-frank-large-q4.sh (no auth header: repo is public
and ungated; size + sha256 verified after transfer). The speculative drafter
and its fetcher are unchanged.
Shape: --sessions 4 --context 163840 with unquantized KV. gufo exposes no KV
quantization lever (execution_policy.hpp pins kv_cache_storage to kFp16), so
f16 is inherent.
KV arithmetic: f16 KV = 64 KiB/token (16 full-attention layers x 4 KV heads x
256 head_dim x 2 x 2B; the other 48 layers are linear-attention with a
per-sequence fp32 state). 4 x 163840 = 655,360 tokens = 40.0 GiB KV, each
session exactly 10 GiB. Budget ~62 GiB of the 114 GiB GTT.
Seam retargeted (FETCH -> the q4 script, TARGET_STUB, context/sessions pins).
The KV pool stays pinned at 606,208 tokens (card is full: 531 MiB free at
the old shape; autofit's 687,388 would leave 0.53 GB and OOM on the first
long request). 2 x 262,144 = 524,288 leaves ~82k tokens of pool slack.
Motivation: harness compaction. frank-primary's contextWindow 262,144
compacts at 70% = 183,501 tokens, and the compaction request carries a
32,768-token summary budget -> 216,269 must fit ONE frank-small request.
The 151,552 slot window could not hold it; the native window does.
No spec-decode interaction: checkpoint ships zero mtp.* tensors (config
lies), seam keeps every --speculative-* flag away from the engine.
Both of Frank's changes at once.
KV is bf16 (--kv-cache-dtype auto) at two full-size windows (2 x 262144).
bf16 measures 13,839 B/token (bf16 3x241664 boot: 11,047,010,304 B -> 798,280
tokens), decomposing as 12,276 attention + 1,563 mamba/side caches vs fp8's
6,138 + 1,563 = 7,701. 524,288 tokens needs 7.256e9 B; pinned at 7.3e9
(~527,500 tokens, 3,206 margin). Pool cost: 5.68 -> 6.76 GiB per rank.
--expert-precise-memory selects the fitted overhead (5.25 GiB) over the default
(7.60 GiB = fitted + compile/graph-capture headroom). It moves only the plan's
term, so the expert arena goes 6,248 -> ~7,278 slots (~1,025 more) at the
cost of boot-time capture slack. Overhead adds 0.22 GiB/1024 nbt above 4096, so
MNBT 2048 pays nothing.
Seam + docs + AGENTS row + log updated.
ExecStop runs 'podman stop -t 120' but the unit never set TimeoutStopSec, so
systemd's 90 s default cut the graceful stop short: journal shows 'Stopping
timed out. Terminating.' then 'Failed with result timeout' on 2026-10-01
13:27:17 — every stop of this unit was logging a failed stop. 180 s covers the
engine's drain with margin, and the seam now guards the RELATIONSHIP
(TimeoutStopSec > the podman grace) rather than a literal.
StartLimitIntervalSec is a [Unit] directive; the copy in [Service] made systemd
log 'Unknown key StartLimitIntervalSec in section Service' on every load. Seam
asserts it appears exactly once and not in [Service].
Frank's call 2026-10-01: MAXLEN 262144 x SEQS 3 = 786,432 tokens of contract.
Measured fp8 KV costs 7,698 B/token (4-slot boot 8,311,013,376 B -> 1,079,582
tokens; 5-slot boot 10,388,766,720 B -> 1,350,182 tokens), so the pool floor
for the contract is 6.054e9 B. Pinned at 6,100,000,000 (~792k tokens, ~5.9k
margin) so the remaining ~2.2 GiB versus the 4-slot shape goes to the expert
ARENA - the fork sizes its decode-critical expert cache from the remainder
after weights, pool and workspace.
MNBT 2048 (Frank): the arena sweep measured 6,499 slots at every rung <= 4096,
so the larger batch costs the arena nothing.
Seam retargeted (3 seqs / 6.1e9 / MNBT 2048); docs + AGENTS row + log updated,
including the closed DCP investigation.
DCP is passed only when FRANK_PRIMARY_DCP is set, so the deployed shape is
unchanged. Verified in this fork: DCP reuses the TP ranks when PCP is
disabled (tp % dcp == 0), so TP=2 + DCP=2 fits the two R9700s with no extra
ranks; the flash_attn backend carries DCP support, the 36 linear-attention
layers of this hybrid do not — which is what the A/B window tests.
Replaces llama.cpp Gemma4-12B-QAT (payload + binary retained as rollback).
SGLang in a self-contained python3.12 venv with an extracted CUDA 13.0
nvcc toolchain for the sgl-kernel/flashinfer JIT.
Shape: fp8 KV, pinned 606,208-token pool / 4 x 151,552 slots, bf16 mamba
states pinned at 32 slots (the engine autofills the ssm pool to a fixed
~5.1 GB regardless of dtype), eager prefill (no headroom for graph
capture), no spec decode (the checkpoint ships no mtp.* tensors despite
mtp_num_hidden_layers=1 — NEXTN drafts with an uninitialised 4.24 GiB
ghost at 0% acceptance).
Verified: 83.9 tok/s decode, 170k single prompt, 4 concurrent 54k
requests, vision (in-checkpoint tower), reasoning_content field.
Five 262144-token contexts passed every boot gate (KV 1,350,182 / 5.15x) but
left 0 bytes free at runtime: a real client request (995-token prompt,
max_tokens=261149, sampling params straight from models.yml) killed Worker_TP1
with torch.OutOfMemoryError 'Tried to allocate 50.00 MiB ... 0 bytes free'.
Boot is not proof of runtime survivability.
Four slots x 262144 fp8 (KV_BYTES 8,311,013,376/rank) returns ~1.93 GiB per
rank for activations/graph capture.
Unit: Restart=always instead of on-failure — a runtime worker fault makes
vLLM's API server exit clean, so ExecStart returned 0 and on-failure never
fired, leaving the endpoint down until a human noticed. Also
StartLimitIntervalSec=0 and OOMScoreAdjust=-500.
Frank's call after the night ladder: five contexts at the model's full native
262,144 window beat six shortened ones. Six full-length contexts do NOT fit at
any KV dtype (6 x 241664 fp8 asked 10.70 GiB against 9.18 GiB free — the
6-seq graph/activation footprint leaves too little for the pool); 5 x 262144
at fp8 PASSED on the first rung: KV_BYTES 10,388,766,720/rank, measured
'GPU KV cache size: 1,350,182 tokens, Maximum concurrency for 262,144 tokens
per request: 5.15x' (39,462 tokens of margin).
Also documented: the SEQS=3 bf16 max (241,664, KV 732,359 / 3.03x) measured
earlier the same night, and the root-cause read that the 7.2 GiB KV ceiling
law was the MTP4 workspace, not VRAM. Seam and harness (contextWindow 262144)
re-pinned.
Night ladder result (Frank's subtract-16k method): 262144 and 245760 both OOM
at CUDA graph capture ('Tried to allocate 76.00 MiB ... 0 bytes free'), 237568
passed (KV 718,606 tokens), and the +4096 bonus step PASSED -> 241664 is max
possible and DEPLOYED at util 0.98 (KV 732,359 tokens / 3.03x concurrency at
241,664-token requests). Util stays 0.98: lowering it shrinks the engine's own
budget instead of buying slack.
Client contract restored (the GLM rollback d91379d dropped all three and the
qwen rollback inherited the gap): --reasoning-parser qwen3 fixes the malformed
thinking block (thinking was landing inline in content with a dangling
</think> and a null reasoning field), --enable-auto-tool-choice with
--tool-call-parser qwen3_xml makes tools work, and
--default-chat-template-kwargs enables enable_thinking + preserve_thinking.
Harness: contextWindow 241664 (compaction gap recomputed), preserve_thinking
moved into chat_template_kwargs.
The 0.98 boot died at KV allocation: torch OOM tried 10.28 GiB (the exact
3x262144 bf16 pool = 11,047,010,304 bytes) with 9.46 GiB free per rank.
The rootless bench probe had booted the same numbers; the root unit's
pinned-expert path holds ~0.8 GiB/rank more. Util 0.90 returns ~2.5 GiB/rank
of workspace with the pool ask unchanged; measured KV capacity law
(798,280 tokens at 11.05e9) unchanged.
Overnight redo campaign verdict + Frank's call: the fp8+MTP4 shape is retired
to git tag frank-primary-fp8-mtp-20261001. The new incumbent: KV cache
unquantized (auto), no speculative decode, KV_BYTES 11,047,010,304/rank
(engine-measured 798,280 tokens, 3.05x concurrency at 262,144-token
requests), MNBT 1024, MoE gather 32x64 (+18.7% decode, grows with depth).
Measured at the deployed shape: 39.38/38.79/36.42 tok/s (166/1087/4064 ctx).
Seam re-pinned: the 7.2 GiB/rank KV ceiling was the MTP4 workspace, not VRAM;
spec decode absent by measurement; bf16 trade documented (clean cache +
262k windows for ~14% decode at 4064 ctx).
- AGENTS.md: fleet table + frank-primary section back to qwen FP8 + MTP4
(37.4-40.6 tok/s, 54% acceptance); GLM runbook moved to the retired index.
- runbook: RETIRED verdict — DFlash2 drafter served and drafted but
acceptance pinned 1.00-1.38 on every text class including verbatim
repetition (mis-wired aux capture, not a weak drafter); 5x slower than
baseline at ~1.2 acceptance.
- log.md: 2026-10-01 rollback entry.
- deploy-remote.sh: LLM_PRIMARY_CONTAINER back to frank-primary-qwen;
glm-probe joins the legacy sweep list.
- frank_primary_unit.bats: re-pinned to the qwen shape — KV qualification
law (7.2 GiB/rank, 3.65x concurrency; 9/16 GiB OOM), fp8 q8/q8 KV
PRESENT, MTP4 PRESENT (3.1-3.4x over the 12.11 no-spec baseline), no tool
dialect, automatic offload. The old 'MTP buys zero' law carried the
prefetch tax and is retired.
DFlash2 experiment declared failed 2026-10-01: the drafter serves and
drafts (12.8 tok/s proposed) but acceptance is pinned at 1.0-1.38 on ALL
text classes including verbatim repetition — the aux-hidden-state capture
semantics are wrong (single-stream entering-state vs post-layer/comb is
the untested alternative). At ~1.2 acceptance the 8-token verify tax makes
decode 5x SLOWER than the 9.9-10.0 baseline (1.6-1.8 tok/s measured).
Restores the verified 37-40 tok/s shape: qwen3.8-flash-next FP8, MTP4,
prefetch off, 200k x 3 seqs, fp8 KV.
use_aux_hidden_state_outputs lives on the gpu_model_runner instance
(gpu_model_runner.py:623/678), not on the spec config, so the first
registry check never fired and the reserve stayed at 13,600 B/token.
Switch to method in {dflash, dspark, extract_hidden_states}.
The dflash boot cleared the unifier and the kpool tail (02/03) and died on
KV capacity: on the generic path the mamba states are NOT aliased into the
MLA pages (the glm5 tensor layout's whole point), so the capacity estimator
demanded ~30.6 GiB fixed against 0.92 GiB available (the plan's KV reserve
registry only knows the target's 13,600 B/token).
Patch 04 keeps the aliased glm5 pool and appends the drafter's uniform
group and per-layer hidden-state groups beside it: grouping partitions
hidden + draft specs, the layout returns a 10-tuple, the builder sizes one
shared backing allocation (pool + extras), and the memory estimator adds
the extras. Patch 04b extends the GLM registry kv_bytes_per_token by the
drafter (4,096 B/token) and hidden-state (5 x hidden x 2 B/token) costs so
the expert plan reserves enough.
Local smoke tests (CPU torch + real spec classes) validate grouping shape,
layout recognition, builder block math and memory accounting against
synthetic GLM+draft+hidden spec sets. Apply-verified: reproduces shas
5521e50b... / 1a623d5c...
Patch 02 (MLA-multiple max page) cleared the KV page-size unifier: the
dflash boot now reaches cudagraph capture. New blocker: the kpool decode
kernel asserts tail_kv_cache.shape[2] == pool_size; KpoolTailSpec pins
block_size == index_kpool, so the unifier's divisible branch must never
grow it. Patch 03 = 02 + a KpoolTailSpec branch that pads page_size_padded
instead. Apply-verified: reproduces patched sha 5093e4b7... Runbook
updated with the full KV grouping journey.
The v4 boot named the actual miss: model_runner.py:425 calls
set_eagle3_aux_hidden_state_layers(self.model) on the instance model_runner
LOADED -- and for GLM-5.3-Flash that is Glm5NextForConditionalGeneration (the
multimodal wrapper; APIServer log: 'Resolved architecture:
Glm5NextForConditionalGeneration'), which wraps the text model as
self.language_model = Glm5NextForCausalLM (glm5next/common/model.py:1113).
v4 put the three presence-checked attributes only on Glm5NextForCausalLM,
so the isinstance check on the conditional still failed with the same
RuntimeError.
v5 adds to BOTH wrappers, MRO-safely (attribute route, no Protocol base):
- Glm5NextForConditionalGeneration: supports_eagle3 / has_own_lm_head /
has_own_embed_tokens + the two methods delegating to self.language_model
(the pixtral.py:498 pattern);
- Glm5NextForCausalLM: the same three attributes + the two methods that
unwrap to self.model (the EagleModelMixin trunk -- v1's correct bodies).
Also proven by MRO simulation: the ForCausalLM's five-base ordering cannot
take SupportsEagle3 as a base in ANY position, so inheritance was never a
viable route for this model.
base 008eeaa2... -> patched bc9913a1..., apply-verified against the pinned
image (patch -p1 reproduces the sha256 and matches the mounted file).
The v4 window boot named the real presence-check rule: isinstance against a
runtime_checkable Protocol walks __protocol_attrs__ (which includes members
inherited from BASE protocols) and getattr_static()s each one off the instance,
breaking on the first missing attribute. SupportsEagleBase declares
has_own_lm_head/has_own_embed_tokens as plain instance-var annotations, so
v3's bare supports_eagle3 flag still failed. Replicated in-image with stock
typing: flag-only class -> False; flag + the two base members -> True.
v4 declares all three on Glm5NextForCausalLM:
supports_eagle3: ClassVar[Literal[True]] = True
has_own_lm_head: bool = False
has_own_embed_tokens: bool = False
(False is correct for the two: the wrapper delegates embed/lm_head to its
trunk. The MRO-safe attribute path is kept from v3.)
base 008eeaa2... -> patched 60f27aad..., apply-verified against the pinned
image (patch -p1 reproduces the sha256 and matches the mounted file).
v2 (inheriting SupportsEagle3 as a base) taught the real lesson: the isinstance
check PASSES and the class then dies at creation with
'Cannot create a consistent method resolution order (MRO) for bases ...'
-- GLM's outer wrapper already inherits vLLM Protocols (SupportsPP,
MixtureOfExperts, HasInnerState, IsHybrid) whose ordering is incompatible with
appending another Protocol base.
v3 avoids the MRO entirely: declare
supports_eagle3: ClassVar[Literal[True]] = True
as a class attribute on Glm5NextForCausalLM. Runtime-checkable Protocols do
presence-based isinstance, so the bare flag satisfies supports_eagle3(model)
without touching the MRO. The aux-layer plumbing stays on the trunk via
EagleModelMixin.
base 008eeaa2... -> patched 4c9a632b..., apply-verified against the pinned
image (patch -p1 reproduces the sha256 and matches the mounted dflash-patch
file byte for byte).
v1 hand-wrote set_aux_hidden_state_layers/get_eagle3_default_aux_hidden_state_layers
and the boot reproduced the identical 'Model does not support EAGLE3 interface'.
Reason: supports_eagle3() is an isinstance check against a runtime-checkable
Protocol whose members include a required ClassVar flag
(interfaces.py:1663 supports_eagle3: ClassVar[Literal[True]] = True), so methods
alone do not satisfy it. Inheriting SupportsEagle3 -- the idiom every model in
this image uses, including the fork's own DFlashLagunaForCausalLM -- supplies the
flag, SupportsEagleBase's has_own_lm_head/has_own_embed_tokens, and working
default implementations of both methods; the hand-written methods are deleted.
base 008eeaa2... -> patched 5eea89c5..., apply-verified against the pinned image.
Runbook: corrected method name, recorded the Protocol trap as the generalizable
lesson for future spec-decode ports.
Clarifies scope in the artifact header: torch.compiler.disable is itself a graph break,
so 05 helps only a hypothetical fullgraph=True route (where the workspace acquisition
would be better restructured out of the forward than made opaque). It is kept because
the discovery is real and the wrapper is a no-op when nothing is compiling, but it is
not required for the break-tolerant route whose only confirmed blocker is the dynamo
name-map KeyError.
Also verified in this pass: glm53-dflash-01-aux-hidden-states.patch applies cleanly to
the pinned image and reproduces its recorded patched sha256 (4ff6ff8d...), so all six
artifacts in scripts/patches are now apply-verified.
glm53-dflash-01-aux-hidden-states.patch: implements the interface whose absence makes
the engine refuse the drafter with 'Model does not support EAGLE3 interface'. Adds
EagleModelMixin to Glm5NextModel, captures the single-stream hidden state entering each
requested layer in the loop, returns (hidden_states, aux_hidden_states) as a tuple when
the list is non-empty, and exposes set_aux_hidden_state_layers /
get_eagle3_default_aux_hidden_state_layers on Glm5NextForCausalLM -- the contract read
out of interfaces.py:1694/1712, eagle3_utils.py:26-31, deepseek_v2.py:1551-1585 and
cudagraph_utils.py:621, with kimi_k25/pixtral as the delegation reference.
Independent of the compile changelist (01-05); it patches the same file as 01, so 01
goes first if both are applied. Scope is honest in the header: this makes the interface
present (the prerequisite for driving DFlash2), it does not promise draft quality and is
not a decode-speed fix.
Five runs of the changelist now reproduce the same single failure with breaks genuinely
tolerated (patch 01+02+03+04, VLLM_COMPILE_FULLGRAPH=0, VLLM_USE_AOT_COMPILE=0,
R4D_GLM_FUSE_QKV_RMSNORM=0): the trunk TRACES ('Dynamo bytecode transform time: 1.08 s')
and the boot dies on KeyError: 'in_proj_qkvbfg_a'.
What it is NOT, each ruled out by measurement rather than argument:
- not one of dynamo's four nn_modules lookups: /home/dank/dynamo-probe wraps three of
them and stayed silent over two runs, with the probe's install line confirmed in both
the API-server and worker processes;
- not a dynamo-internal failure: TORCHDYNAMO_VERBOSE=1 adds no internal stack trace;
- not a literal string lookup: the name appears tree-wide only as the KDA layer's
attribute (kda.py:217, used at :407) and in the load_weights shard table
(model.py:780-785); the four sites in the
quantization utils do compute exactly this bare key but every one is guarded
(), so none can raise it;
- not the pluggable-layer registry, which is keyed by class name.
What it IS: a plain Python KeyError raised inside the traced
Glm5NextDecoderLayer.forward, in a callee dynamo INLINED (frame chain
profile_run -> _dummy_run -> execute_model -> glm4_1v.py:2358 -> the compile wrapper ->
eval_frame.compile_wrapper -> Glm5NextModel.forward:748 -> module._call_impl ->
Glm5NextDecoderLayer.forward:456; the reported line is that method's def line, which is
how inlined frames surface).
Patch 03's header and the runbook now record the remaining instrument (TORCH_LOGS=+dynamo
and grep, or wrap the inlining candidates — the mHC CustomOps and the indexer op — with a
KeyError probe), and the two breaks that are real but non-fatal in this configuration
(patch 04's fused-norm launcher cell, patch 05's workspace acquisition).
tests/run.sh: 362 seams pass.
Frank
Comrade Chief Designer
Comrade Chief Designer